We think we’ll get to say goodbye, but nobody really promises you that.
Dad was by himself in the early morning dark. The last time I saw him, I had only a few moments before we had to leave, and I spent them telling him the dumbest jokes I could find online. After we left, he didn’t realize we weren’t there anymore because his eyesight had failed. My brother, Larry, hearing him still telling us goodbye, ran back into the room to give him another hug. I told myself that if I never had the chance to talk to him again, leaving him laughing was as good as it gets.
Sometimes I believe it.
When Mom passed, I hadn’t seen her in more than five years. The reasons were ours. She’s gone. Now I just carry them alone.
When she’d talk about me coming down—sometimes asking, sometimes suggesting, sometimes something harsher—I’d think, I may well see you one more time, but you might not know I’m there.
I was right.
That, too, is mine alone to carry.
When I said goodbye to River Garden, the complex where Dad and then Mom lived out their last days, it was a heavier parting than I’d realized it would be. With Mom still living there, the keeper of the photos and memories, Dad had somehow remained, too. It never occurred to me that when we cleaned out her place, we’d be breaking down both their lives and moving them out.
Her things. His.
There is no next generation. No one to pass anything to. So you sell what someone will pay for. You give away what will be loved or merely used.
Then you throw away everything else. Even that which was most beloved. What hung on the walls of the house you lived in for all your growing years—and wherever they called home in the years after that.
Thirty outside Philadelphia. Thirty more in Jacksonville.
Someone will throw it out for you if you don’t. It’s only a matter of time.
Weddings. Parties. A vintage Rawlings mitt. The terrifying clowns. My great-grandmother’s table-clamp meatgrinder, which helped make enough chopped liver to capsize a container ship. Awards and notes and appointment reminders and people you don’t recognize and dancing and costumes and poses and smiles and laughter and captures of what was once happy but now breaks your heart.
Gone.
You talk to them while you do it. You say you’re sorry through your tears, when you’re able to say anything at all.
I kept Dad’s dog tags from World War II, the Kiddush cup I was given as a baby—my Hebrew reading proficiency is rusty at best, and that’s being kind, but I still recognize my own name—and my grandfather’s shaving mug.
Our last night, I sat outside and used the Kiddush cup to toast the place and the home they were able to make in it, along with their memories. Accompanied by Larry; my wife, Renée; and a pair of Canada geese, I silently thanked the friends, neighbors, and staff members who packed the memorial service we held, along with everyone who helped and spoke.
The woman in the “I [Heart] Hadassah” shirt who said she always thought my dad was so cute.
The Action News Jax anchorman who told the crowded room he’d received “just a few” emails from Mom over the years with her take on his broadcasts, unfurling enough taped-together pages to reach the floor, before he found himself overcome and unable to speak for a moment.
God bless Mom. She’d be so happy to know that in the end, she silenced a man who talks for a living, if only for a few long seconds.
All the ladies who showed up in the kind of bright colors Mom favored, wearing the items she’d cajoled them into buying at the gift shop. Which says something about how she raised $100,000 for the home in her time running it. And she was still ordering and merchandising when she passed at 90.
They needed the memorial service, people said. She’d left for a routine procedure and never came back, though they’d only just spoken to her a day or two before. They needed to say goodbye.
Don’t we all.
I took pictures of whatever grabbed my eye, even if it would only have meaning for me. The turtle pond we used to roll Dad out to. The table from our Dresher living room, which sat in the hallway outside Mom’s room for the last few years. Word is they’re going to use it outside the dining room to display the dishes on offer each night.
Whatever people will love or use.
As we pulled out of the parking lot for the last time, a woman passing stopped to roll down her window and tell us how much she’d appreciated the service.
And when the plane took off, and I knew I wouldn’t be back, I had to push myself up from my seat to make out the ground fading below us so I could thank the place one last time.
You mostly don’t get to say your goodbyes the way you’d hoped.
So you do the best you can.
Just like you did in all the years leading up to that.
Time it was,
And what a time it was
It was . . .
A time of innocence
A time of confidences
Long ago . . . it must be . . .
I have a photograph
Preserve your memories
They’re all that’s left you















